SiteTo.App

Back to Blog
Technology

The Future of Progressive Web Apps vs. Native Apps

Emily RodriguezNovember 15, 20239 min read

The Future of Progressive Web Apps vs. Native Apps

*By Emily Rodriguez • November 15, 2023 • 9 min read*

When businesses look to expand their mobile presence, they often face a critical decision: should they invest in Progressive Web Apps (PWAs) or traditional native mobile applications? Both approaches offer distinct advantages and limitations that can significantly impact user experience, development resources, and business outcomes.

In this article, we'll explore the key differences between PWAs and native apps, current market trends, and how to determine which approach best aligns with your business goals.

What Are Progressive Web Apps (PWAs)?

Progressive Web Apps are web applications that use modern web capabilities to deliver app-like experiences to users. They function in browsers but can offer features traditionally associated with native apps:

Key Characteristics of PWAs:

  • Work offline or with poor network connectivity
  • Can be installed on the device home screen
  • Load quickly with smooth animations
  • Support push notifications (on compatible browsers)
  • Access some device features (camera, geolocation, etc.)
  • Update automatically when new versions are available

    • What Are Native Apps?

    Native apps are applications built specifically for particular operating systems (primarily iOS and Android) using platform-specific programming languages and SDKs:

    Key Characteristics of Native Apps:

  • Distributed through app stores (App Store, Google Play)
  • Full access to device hardware and OS features
  • Optimized performance for the specific platform
  • Ability to function completely offline
  • Integrated with platform-specific features (Apple Pay, Google Play services, etc.)
  • Benefit from app store discovery

    • Head-to-Head Comparison

    Development Resources

    PWAs:

  • Single codebase for all platforms
  • Built using web technologies (HTML, CSS, JavaScript)
  • Faster development cycles
  • Lower development costs
  • Easier maintenance

    • Native Apps:

  • Separate codebases for iOS and Android
  • Platform-specific development skills required
  • Longer development timelines
  • Higher development costs
  • More complex maintenance

    • *Real-world impact:* A retail client found that developing a PWA cost approximately 70% less than building equivalent native apps for both major platforms.

    User Experience

    PWAs:

  • Improving but still limited access to native features
  • Consistent experience across platforms
  • No installation required for basic use
  • Lightweight (no large downloads)
  • Sometimes less smooth performance for complex interactions

    • Native Apps:

  • Full access to platform capabilities
  • Platform-optimized UI/UX patterns
  • Better performance for graphics-intensive applications
  • More reliable offline functionality
  • Deeper integration with OS features

    • *Real-world impact:* Gaming and graphic-intensive applications still show significant performance advantages as native apps, with up to 3x better performance metrics in high-demand scenarios.

    Distribution and Discovery

    PWAs:

  • No app store approval process
  • Instant updates without app store delays
  • Discoverable through web search engines
  • Shareable via URLs
  • Limited visibility compared to app stores
  • No built-in monetization infrastructure

    • Native Apps:

  • App store discovery (browse, search, featured apps)
  • App store trust signals and reviews
  • Streamlined in-app purchase mechanisms
  • Update approval delays
  • Installation friction (download size, permissions)

    • *Real-world impact:* A media company saw 24% higher user acquisition costs for their native app compared to their PWA due to app store fees and competitive paid acquisition.

    Performance and Capabilities

    PWAs:

  • Getting better with each browser update
  • Still limited access to some hardware features
  • Inconsistent implementation across browsers
  • Smaller footprint on device storage
  • Performance gap narrowing for standard applications

    • Native Apps:

  • Superior performance for intensive applications
  • Full access to all device capabilities
  • Consistent behavior within each platform
  • Better integration with platform-specific services
  • Higher storage requirements

    • *Real-world impact:* Video streaming services report 15-30% better battery efficiency with native apps for long viewing sessions compared to PWA equivalents.

    Current Market Trends

    The landscape continues to evolve rapidly:

  • **Growing PWA Adoption**

    • - Major brands like Twitter, Starbucks, and Pinterest have invested heavily in PWAs

    - Google continues to champion PWA technology and standards

    - PWA capability support expands with each major browser update

  • **App Store Dominance Continues**

    • - App stores still drive the majority of mobile app discovery

    - iOS and Android platforms maintain tight control over their ecosystems

    - User expectations for "legitimate" apps still lean toward native

  • **Hybrid Solutions Gaining Ground**

    • - Frameworks like React Native and Flutter reduce the native development gap

    - Website-to-app conversion services (like SiteTo.App) offer the best of both worlds

    - Companies increasingly maintain both PWA and native presences

  • **Apple's Stance Evolving**

    • - Historically reluctant to fully support PWA capabilities on iOS

    - Gradually improving PWA feature support in Safari

    - Still maintains significant limitations compared to Android

    Making the Right Choice for Your Business

    When deciding between PWAs and native apps, consider these key factors:

    Consider PWAs When:

  • **Budget constraints** are significant
  • **Time-to-market** is critical
  • Your application has **moderate performance requirements**
  • **Cross-platform consistency** is a high priority
  • **Web search discovery** is important to your strategy
  • You need **frequent, immediate updates**
  • Your app doesn't require advanced device features

    • Consider Native Apps When:

  • **Performance** is critical to your app's success
  • You need **complete access** to device hardware
  • **App store presence** is essential for your market
  • **User engagement and retention** are primary goals
  • Your app requires **extensive offline capabilities**
  • You have the resources for platform-specific development
  • **In-app purchases** are a core revenue stream

    • Consider a Hybrid Approach When:

  • You want to **start with a PWA** but plan to expand to native later
  • Different user segments have **different needs** (casual vs. power users)
  • You need to **validate your concept** before full native investment
  • Your business model supports **both channels** effectively

    • Case Study: Media Company's Dual Approach

    A major media company took a strategic approach to this decision:

  • They launched a **PWA first** to capture casual readers and search traffic
  • After 6 months of data collection, they identified their **power users**
  • They developed a **native app** targeting these high-value users with premium features
  • The PWA continued serving as an **acquisition channel**

    • 5. This dual approach resulted in **30% more total engaged users** than either approach alone

    The Third Option: Website-to-App Conversion

    For many businesses, especially those with established websites, services like SiteTo.App offer a compelling alternative:

  • **Start with your existing website** rather than rebuilding from scratch
  • **Convert to native apps** without the typical development costs
  • **Maintain a single content base** that updates both web and apps
  • **Add native-only features** selectively where they add the most value
  • **Gain app store presence** without completely rebuilding your digital product

    • This approach has proven particularly effective for:

  • Content-focused businesses
  • E-commerce platforms
  • Service-based companies
  • Media organizations
  • Community platforms

    • Looking to the Future

    Several trends will likely shape this landscape in coming years:

  • **Browser Capabilities** will continue to expand, narrowing the gap between PWAs and native apps
  • **App Store Policies** may evolve in response to regulatory pressure, potentially creating more openness
  • **Development Tools** will further reduce the resources needed for maintaining multiple platforms
  • **User Expectations** will increasingly demand app-like experiences regardless of platform

    • 5. **Conversion Technologies** will continue advancing, making it easier to maintain both web and app presences

    Conclusion

    The PWA vs. native app debate doesn't necessarily have a universal answer. The right approach depends on your specific business needs, resources, target audience, and long-term digital strategy.

    For many businesses, the most practical path forward isn't choosing between PWAs and native apps, but finding ways to efficiently leverage both approaches. Solutions like SiteTo.App were created specifically to address this challenge, allowing businesses to maintain a strong web presence while also capitalizing on the benefits of native mobile apps.

    Whatever path you choose, the most important factor is alignment with your users' needs and your business objectives. The technology should serve your strategy, not dictate it.

    ---

    *Interested in exploring how your website could work as both a PWA and native mobile apps? [Contact our team](/company/contact) for a personalized assessment.*

    Share this article